Mariah May’s wrestling future is now the talk of the town after AEW officially removed her profile from its website—a move that typically signals a wrestler’s exit. With reports from PWInsider confirming that May is expected to sign with WWE soon, fans are buzzing about her next big move.
May has been absent from AEW programming since her loss to Toni Storm at AEW Revolution 2025, but the signs of her departure were already there. Her public comments have hinted at frustration with her treatment in AEW, especially after a controversial Chicago trip.
In a vlog filmed during that trip, May expressed her disappointment about her hotel accommodations, saying:
“So, I’m coming to you from Chicago. I checked the view, but there’s not really anything to write home about. I got really screwed over with the rooms. Everybody came in my room. I was like, ‘Oh.’ I’m like, ‘What do you mean?’ Oh. So, I feel like everyone else has like a gorgeous view of the skyline. I’m not killing it so much. But I am tapping into this vlog. So, I’m in Chicago for Dynamite and Rampage, which we’re filming today.”
This wasn’t an isolated incident. When a fan pointed out the discrepancy in hotel treatment on Twitter, May cryptically replied:
“What’s new.”
That response fueled speculation that May’s frustrations with AEW were longstanding and unresolved. Rumors of her departure have been swirling for months, and today’s removal from AEW’s official roster confirms she’s out of the company.
PWInsider reports that WWE is already eyeing Mariah May, with sources expecting her to join the company soon. This potential move aligns with earlier reports from Dave Meltzer of Wrestling Observer, who noted that May had previously informed AEW that she wouldn’t renew her contract upon its expiration.
Fans are eager to see how May’s talents will translate to WWE’s bigger stage. Her charisma, in-ring skills, and social media presence make her an ideal fit for the company’s growing women’s division.
As of now, May is enjoying some downtime while weighing her options. Only time will tell what direction her wrestling journey will take next.
💬 Do you think Mariah May will shine in WWE? Drop your thoughts below!